Cell phones and internet have become basic business tools. If you run an incorporated business in Canada, work from home, or have employees working remotely, it is common for the corporation to pay for or reimburse some of these costs.

But does paying the bill through the company automatically create a taxable benefit for the employee?

Not necessarily.

The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) has specific administrative policies for employer-paid cell phones, cell phone plans and home internet. The tax treatment also depends on what is being paid, how it is being paid and whether there is personal use.

Here is what Canadian business owners should know.

Cell Phone Plans Can Often Be Paid Without a Taxable Benefit

CRA generally allows an employer to provide or reimburse an employee for a cell phone service plan without creating a taxable benefit when all of the following conditions are met:

  • the employee is required to use the cell phone service as part of their employment duties;
  • the plan has a reasonable fixed cost; and
  • the employee’s personal use does not result in additional charges above the fixed cost of the plan.

In other words, CRA does not necessarily require you to calculate a business-use percentage simply because an employee occasionally uses their work phone personally.

Consider an employee who needs a cell phone to communicate with clients. The employer pays a reasonable $70-per-month unlimited plan. The employee occasionally uses the phone personally, but that personal use does not increase the monthly bill.

Provided the plan is reasonable for the employee’s work requirements, CRA’s administrative policy may allow the entire service plan to be treated as non-taxable.

That can be considerably simpler than trying to track every business and personal call.

What does “reasonable” mean?

There isn’t one dollar amount that CRA considers reasonable for every employee.

Instead, the employer needs to consider what the employee reasonably requires to perform their job. Someone who travels extensively, regularly communicates with clients or needs significant mobile data may reasonably require a more expensive plan than someone who rarely uses their phone for work.

The employer should be prepared to explain why the plan is reasonable based on the employee’s employment duties.

What If Personal Use Creates Additional Charges?

This changes the situation.

If an employee incurs additional charges because of personal use — perhaps international roaming charges or other usage outside the regular plan — the additional personal amount will generally be a taxable benefit unless the employee reimburses the employer.

For example:

An employee has an $80 fixed monthly business phone plan paid by their employer. While travelling personally, the employee incurs an additional $50 of roaming charges.

The regular $80 plan may qualify for CRA’s non-taxable administrative treatment, but the $50 personal roaming charge would generally be a taxable benefit unless the employee pays the $50 back to the company.

What About the Actual Cell Phone?

This is where it is important to distinguish between the phone itself and the monthly service plan.

If the employer purchases and owns the cell phone and requires the employee to use it for their employment duties, CRA’s administrative policy provides that the value of the device itself is not a taxable benefit.

However, if the employee buys the phone personally and the employer reimburses the employee for the purchase, CRA says the reimbursement for the device is a taxable benefit — even where the employee uses the phone for their job.

This can also matter with those increasingly common cell phone contracts where part of your monthly payment represents the cost of financing the phone.

For example, assume the corporation reimburses an employee $75 per month consisting of:

  • $55 for a reasonable fixed-cost service plan; and
  • $20 toward the purchase of the employee’s phone.

If the service plan otherwise meets CRA’s requirements, the $55 service component may be non-taxable. However, the $20-per-month reimbursement for the employee-owned phone would generally be taxable. CRA specifically illustrates this distinction in its guidance.

Home Internet Is Treated Differently

Internet is a little less generous.

If an employer pays or reimburses an employee’s home internet service, CRA states that the business-use portion is not a taxable benefit, while the personal-use portion is taxable.

Suppose an employee’s home internet costs $100 per month and the employer reimburses the entire amount.

If a reasonable assessment determined that 60% relates to employment and 40% relates to personal use:

  • $60 would relate to employment; and
  • $40 would represent personal use.

The personal portion reimbursed by the employer would generally be a taxable benefit.

This is an important distinction from a qualifying fixed-cost cell phone plan. There is no equivalent CRA administrative policy that simply ignores incidental personal use of home internet because the monthly price did not increase.

Reimbursement Versus an Allowance Matters

Another common mistake is assuming that paying an employee a flat monthly amount is the same as reimbursing an expense.

It isn’t.

An allowance is generally a predetermined amount paid to the employee without requiring the employee to substantiate the actual expense.

For example:

“We will give every employee $75 per month toward their phone and internet.”

CRA specifically states that its administrative policy for cell phone and internet services does not apply to allowances. A cell phone or internet allowance is taxable to the employee.

Compare that with:

“Submit your monthly cell phone bill and the company will reimburse the qualifying cost.”

That is a reimbursement, and the appropriate CRA rules for the particular expense can then be applied.

The wording may sound similar, but the payroll tax result can be very different.

What If You Own the Corporation?

This is particularly relevant for incorporated small business owners.

You might be the shareholder, director and employee of your corporation all at the same time.

Being a shareholder does not automatically prevent you from receiving legitimate employment benefits. However, CRA requires you to determine whether a benefit was received because you are an employee or because you are a shareholder.

That distinction matters.

CRA specifically lists a corporation paying a shareholder’s personal expenses as a potential shareholder benefit. A shareholder benefit has different tax consequences from an employee benefit and is generally not deductible by the corporation as an ordinary employee compensation expense.

So simply putting your family’s phone plans or home internet bill through the corporation because “the company pays my bills” is not the approach we recommend.

Instead, there should be a reasonable connection between the expense and the work you perform for the corporation.

For an owner-manager who spends significant time speaking with clients, answering emails, using accounting software, working remotely or otherwise requiring connectivity to operate the business, that connection may be very straightforward.

The important part is documenting and treating the expense consistently with its actual business purpose.

What Should Employers Keep on File?

You don’t need to turn this into an administrative nightmare, but some documentation is worthwhile.

For cell phones, consider documenting:

  • why the employee requires the phone for their job;
  • the monthly plan and cost;
  • why the plan is reasonable for that employee’s duties;
  • whether the plan includes financing for the physical device; and
  • any unusual personal charges paid by the company.

For internet reimbursements, establish a reasonable method for determining the business-use portion and retain support for the calculation.

Additional considerations for shareholder-employees: documentation becomes even more important because you want to demonstrate that the corporation is paying the expense in connection with your employment or the operation of the business — rather than simply paying a shareholder’s personal expenses.

What Happens If the Amount Is Taxable?

Where there is a taxable employee benefit, it generally needs to be processed through payroll and reported on the employee’s T4.

CRA’s current guidance distinguishes between cash benefits, such as certain allowances, and non-cash or near-cash benefits when determining CPP, EI, income tax withholding and GST/HST obligations. Taxable employee cell phone and internet benefits are reported as employment income, including under Code 40 on the T4.

This is one reason it is better to identify these items during the year rather than discovering them while preparing T4s — or several years later during a CRA payroll review.

The Practical Takeaway

For most incorporated businesses, the answer isn’t simply “the company can pay your phone” or “you have to claim only the business percentage.”

The details matter.

A reasonable fixed-cost cell phone service plan required for employment can often be employer-paid without creating a taxable benefit, even where there is some incidental personal use.

Home internet is different: the business-use portion can generally be paid without a taxable benefit, while an employer-paid personal portion is generally taxable.

The purchase of the physical phone is different again. An employer-owned phone required for work can generally be provided without a taxable benefit under CRA’s administrative policy, while reimbursing an employee for a phone they personally purchased generally creates a taxable benefit.

And paying a flat phone or internet allowance is not the same as reimbursing an actual qualifying expense — CRA considers the allowance taxable.

For incorporated business owners, there is one additional question: Is the corporation paying the expense because you need it for your work, or simply because you are the shareholder?

Keeping that distinction in mind — and keeping reasonable documentation — can prevent a relatively small monthly expense from turning into an unnecessary payroll or shareholder-benefit problem later.

Want more? Here are a few great resources:

 

Disclaimer: This article provides general information about Canadian tax matters and is not intended as tax, legal or accounting advice. Tax treatment depends on the specific facts and circumstances, and CRA administrative policies and legislation may change. Speak with your CPA or other qualified advisor about how these rules apply to your particular situation.